'Slap in the face:' Paramus mayor threatens to sue American Dream mall over Sunday sales

‘Slap in the face:’ Paramus mayor threatens to sue American Dream mall over Sunday sales

Posted by author January 25, 2025 Shopping

Paramus officials say they’re exploring a lawsuit against American Dream after learning that retail shops at the Meadowlands megamall are open for business on Sundays in defiance of Bergen County’s Blue Laws.

The stores at American Dream have been operating in violation of those laws for nearly a year, The Record and NorthJersey.com reported this month, despite the county’s longstanding prohibitions against the sale of nonessential items such as furniture, appliances and clothing. The restrictions, in place since the 17th century, exempt some services, including groceries and drugstores.

Paramus residents in particular have been proponents of the Blue Laws over the years. Supporters say the laws grant them a day of reprieve from the heavy traffic that plagues the borough the rest of the week due to its four malls.

Mayor Chris DiPiazza said Thursday that he, the Borough Council, local businesses and residents are all “very upset” about American Dream’s Sunday sales.

Story continues below photo gallery.

“The businesses in town are now at a disadvantage and unlevel playing field, which had been level for decades,” said DiPiazza, a Republican.

Borough officials have been meeting with a lawyer to investigate legal options, the mayor said. He said Paramus has also turned to state representatives and county government for help, though DiPiazza declined to identify them before they officially announced their support.

Blue Laws key to ‘our way of life,’ mayor says

“Being mayor of Paramus, I know how important the Blue Laws are to our way of life and the peacefulness of Sundays,” he said in an interview. They give us “the ability to move around town, the ability for our emergency services to have less calls and regroup. As mayor, I’m going to fight like heck for Paramus and the county as a whole.”

DiPiazza said that when he hears executives at American Dream are “flaunting that they are open on Sundays,” it’s a “slap in the face to the residents of Paramus and Bergen County as a whole.”

County officials have also vowed to fight to make the mall comply.

Westfield Garden State Plaza, Paramus’ biggest mall, didn’t reply to a message asking how it might respond to American Dream’s Sunday activity. Instead, Stephen Fluhr, senior vice president of development at owner Unibail-Rodamco-Westfield, said the shopping center “continues to only operate its entertainment and dining options on Sundays in accordance with both Bergen County and Paramus blue laws.”

“Our guests can enjoy their favorite restaurants, the Food Court District, and our premier entertainment concepts like Planet Playskool, Pinstripes and AMC Theatres year-round on Sundays,” Fluhr said in a statement.

American Dream responds

A spokesperson for American Dream declined to comment on Friday. In a statement this month, Don Ghermezian, CEO of Triple Five, the Canadian company that owns the mall, said the business was “ecstatic that our extensive list of offerings operates on Sundays, allowing everyone to enjoy the very best of American Dream whenever they want.”

Spokespeople for two other major Paramus malls, Bergen Town Center and Paramus Park, also declined to comment when reached Friday.

Staff Writer Daniel Munoz contributed to this article.

Stephanie Noda is a local reporter for NorthJersey.com. For unlimited access to the most important news from your local community, please subscribe or activate your digital account today.

Email: noda@northjersey.com; X: @snoda11