Sabalenka was the pre-match favourite, having won 33 of her previous 34 matches on the Australian hard courts.
But Keys, a powerful baseliner, is one of the few players on the WTA Tour who has the weapons to damage Sabalenka.
The explosive match-up led to a gripping final where Keys won only one more point overall.
A stunning opening set, where she whacked 11 winners and had a rock-solid first serve, set the platform.
Keys was also helped by a nervy start from Sabalenka, whose once-unstable second serve returned to trouble her.
Two double faults in the opening game allowed Keys to break, while another set up a second break point in the fifth game which Sabalenka handed over with a sliced forehand into the net.
Keys continued to play lights out, thumping clean winners from the back of the court and also showing deft touches.
A bemused Sabalenka could only smile when Keys pulled out an ice-cold drop-shot on the way to holding for 5-1.
However, Sabalenka was furious with herself after a fourth double fault handed over another set point, which Keys took with a backhand winner.
“She played super aggressive. It seemed like everything was going her way,” said Sabalenka.
“I was just trying to put the ball back. I couldn’t really play my aggressive tennis and didn’t feel my serve that well.”
Danielle Collins has vowed to gift Novak Djokovic some of her merchandise after the Serb offered his support to the WTA star. Collins hasn’t been afraid to sp
What a year this has been for American women’s tennis! We’ve seen plenty of title triumphs, but if asked to single out one big win among those, it’d surel
A former American tennis superstar has leaped to Coco Gauff’s defense after the 20-year-old phenom faced backlash for her recent Oscars appearance—a glamoro
A former American tennis great has sparked a firestorm in sports debates by declaring Novak Djokovic the greatest athlete of the modern era—surpassing icons l