Week 17 of the 2024 fantasy football season featured big surprises. Who were the big winners and losers? Which players received A and F grades?
Matt Bowen and Tristan H. Cockcroft offer their analysis, and Seth Walder provides his grades.
Jump to a topic:
Ranking winners | Ranking losers
Who got an A | Who got an F
Biggest injuries and what’s next
1. Baker Mayfield, QB; Mike Evans, WR, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
With a matchup against the talent-deficient Panthers defense, Mayfield hit season highs across the board in points (34.56), passing yards (359) and touchdowns (five). Mayfield was absolutely dialed in, completing 84.4% of his throws. Evans, who scored 29.7 points, caught eight of his nine targets for 97 yards, including two low red zone touchdown receptions. With a Week 18 matchup against a Saints team just playing out the schedule, Mayfield will remain a locked-in QB1. You can bet on that, while Evans fits here as a lower-tier WR1. — Bowen
Why fantasy managers should trust Baker Mayfield in Week 18
Eric Karabell breaks down fantasy managers should be confident in Baker Mayfield as a solid QB1 in Week 18.
2. Joe Burrow, QB, and Tee Higgins, WR, Cincinnati Bengals
A good number of fantasy managers who advanced to their leagues’ championship matchups in ESPN leagues had Burrow (26.0%, fourth most among quarterbacks) and/or Higgins (24.9%, 12th most among wide receivers), and those individuals were certainly pleased with their Saturday contributions. Burrow overcame seven sacks and Ja’Marr Chase running 43-of-56 routes aligned across from top cover corner Pat Surtain II to score a season-best 36.98 fantasy points, capped by a 3-yard winning touchdown pass to Higgins, whose 40.1 PPR fantasy points were the second most of his career (43.4, Week 16 of 2021). Burrow now has 211.52 points over the past nine weeks, second most among quarterbacks behind only Josh Allen in that span, and third most at the position for the season. Higgins’ 19.4 points per game are fourth best among wide receivers.
Best yet: With the Bengals’ win, they’re mathematically alive in the AFC playoff race, meaning plenty of motivation for the team for a Week 18 road game against the Pittsburgh Steelers. Tough matchup or not, Burrow, Higgins and Chase each scored 17-plus points in the teams’ Week 13 meeting, and all three should be mainstays in your final-week lineup. — Cockcroft
3. Malik Nabers, WR, (and Drew Lock, QB,) New York Giants
In what has been a lost season for the Giants, Nabers has nevertheless developed into a fantasy superstar. His 36.1 PPR fantasy points Sunday set a personal best, and his seven receptions gave him 104, tied with Jaylen Waddle (2021) for third most by a rookie behind Brock Bowers (he set a record this week and has 108) and Puka Nacua (105, 2023). Nabers has done this despite working with four different quarterbacks, three of whom have made starts over the past eight weeks. He’ll be a fantasy WR1 for Week 18 against a Philadelphia Eagles team that’ll surely be resting regulars. Lock, meanwhile, obliterated his previous personal best for fantasy points by scoring 34.36 in the team’s stunning 45-33 upset of the Indianapolis Colts. Managers who started him in 0.3% of ESPN leagues were surely pleasantly surprised. — Cockcroft
4. Trey McBride, TE, Arizona Cardinals
He finally scored a touchdown. McBride had caught 92 touchdown-less passes entering the week, the most without a score by any player through 15 team games in NFL history. On Saturday, he caught 12 passes for the third time in six games and scored a career-high 30.3 PPR fantasy points. Unfortunately, a pass that deflected off his helmet led to a game-sealing interception by the Los Angeles Rams, but that misstep shouldn’t dissuade McBride’s fantasy managers from rolling him out there with confidence for Week 18. — Cockcroft
5. Lamar Jackson, QB, Baltimore Ravens
He set the NFL record for career rushing yards by a quarterback (6,110, surpassing Michael Vick), and became the 19th player, and sixth quarterback, to reach the 400 fantasy-point threshold in a single season with his 29.42 points on Christmas Day. Jackson, the most common player found on ESPN finalists’ rosters (38.0% of leagues), seems likely to propel many of his teams to league titles in what has been an MVP-caliber 2024. His Ravens still need a victory in Week 18 to clinch the AFC North title, and with it an opening-week home playoff game, while Jackson will need 8.29 points to break his previous season best (415.68, 2019), and 10.01 to break Patrick Mahomes‘ single-season record for fantasy points by a quarterback (417.40, 2022). — Cockcroft
6. Ladd McConkey, WR, Los Angeles Chargers
McConkey’s 29.4 points in the road win at New England were a season-high, and he once again displayed his ability to uncover at all three levels of the route tree. Beat man-coverage. Or find the zone windows. Just get open. McConkey caught eight of a team-high 10 targets in this one for 94 yards, plus he added two touchdown receptions. McConkey, who has now scored at least one touchdown in two of his past three games, should be played as a solid WR2 in the Week 18 game against the Raiders. — Bowen
Why fantasy managers should be thrilled with Ladd McConkey’s future
Eric Moody breaks down Ladd McConkey’s future in fantasy after a productive rookie season.
7. DeVonta Smith, WR, Philadelphia Eagles
No Jalen Hurts, no problem. With Kenny Pickett as his starter, and Tanner McKee on in relief of an injured Pickett late, Smith scored a season-best 30.0 PPR fantasy points, hauling in a 20-plus-yard touchdown pass from each quarterback. Unfortunately, with Smith’s Eagles wrapping up the NFC East title Sunday, and likely to earn the No. 2 seed in the conference, he’ll probably rest for a good share of Week 18. — Cockcroft
8. Marvin Mims Jr., WR, Denver Broncos
Mims played his best football of the season in the Saturday matchup at Cincinnati, dropping a career-high 30.2 points on the Bengals defense. Mims got the volume (eight targets), and he was schemed-up on his first touchdown grab to attack split-safety coverage off a perfect 51-yard deep-ball throw from Bo Nix. Mims also added another touchdown late in the fourth quarter, and he finished with 103 receiving yards. Mims has now had at least four targets — and a carry — in five straight games, and it’s pretty clear the Broncos are maximizing his traits based on the game plan. You can roll with Mims as an upside WR3 for the Week 18 game versus a Chiefs defense that is expected to rest key players. — Bowen
9. Adam Thielen, WR, Carolina Panthers
Thielen’s 28 points, and 110 yards receiving, in a loss to the Bucs were both season highs, and he did that on only five catches. Thielen caught two touchdowns, and has scored 15 or more points in four of his past five games. Even with his play speed declining, Thielen uses his savvy route running (and coverage awareness) to get loose for quarterback Bryce Young. Heading into Week 18 against the Falcons, managers can play Thielen as a WR3/Flex. — Bowen
1. Joe Mixon, RB, Houston Texans
The Ravens’ 31-2 blowout of Mixon’s Texans resulted in the running back quickly becoming a nonfactor, as he had only two rushing attempts and one target across seven possessions from the two-minute warning of the first half through the game’s conclusion. It counts on the fantasy scoresheet, unfortunately, and Mixon’s 5.9 PPR fantasy points were his season worst and seventh fewest in 110 career games. Though Mixon’s Week 18 matchup against the Tennessee Titans looks good on paper, the Texans’ being locked into the AFC’s No. 4 playoff seed means it’s highly likely he and their other starters will be resting. — Cockcroft
2. Rhamondre Stevenson, RB, New England Patriots
Though Patriots head coach Jerod Mayo threatened to start Antonio Gibson ahead of Stevenson on Saturday because of Stevenson’s fumbling issues, Stevenson ultimately got the starting assignment. But he was quickly removed from the equation in a 40-7 blowout loss to the Los Angeles Chargers, attempting only two carries while getting only one target. Stevenson’s 0.1 PPR fantasy points tied his worst output in any of his 56 career games. He’ll next match up against a Buffalo Bills team likely to be sitting regulars as the AFC’s No. 2 seed, but with the possibility that Gibson, who had 12 rushing attempts, might share or take the majority of the work, Stevenson isn’t a recommended fantasy play. — Cockcroft
3. Aaron Rodgers, QB; Davante Adams, WR; Breece Hall, RB, New York Jets
The Jets played like a team that had checked out for the season in the blowout loss to the Bills. Rodgers posted a season-low 0.48 points, finishing with just 112 yards passing and two picks. Adams caught five of eight targets, but for only 47 yards (9.7 points). And Hall logged 53 total yards on 11 touches (6.3 points). Rough numbers in the fantasy playoffs. The Jets’ offense will look to bounce back in Week 18 against the Dolphins, but I get it if managers have a hard time trusting this unit in the final week of a brutal football season. — Bowen
4. Jaxon Smith-Njigba, WR, Seattle Seahawks
In the Thursday night game against the Bears, one in which Seattle used a more run-heavy script, Smith-Njigba scored only 6.2 points, his lowest total since Week 7. And after getting 12 targets in back-to-back games, Smith-Njigba logged only six Thursday, catching three for 32 yards. JSN gets the Rams in Week 18, a defense he scored a season-high 37 points against in Week 9. And I would expect the Seahawks to test that L.A. secondary with the pass game, which keeps Smith-Njigba in the WR2 mix. — Bowen
5. Cooper Kupp, WR, Los Angeles Rams
Kupp scored only 3.9 points in the Saturday night win over the Cardinals, logging one catch — on three targets — for 29 yards. And over his past three games, Kupp simply hasn’t been a factor in the offense. During this stretch, Kupp has failed to score over six points in a game, and the volume isn’t there. Kupp hasn’t had more than three targets since Week 14, while Puka Nacua continues to operate as the clear No. 1 for Matthew Stafford. Heading into the Week 18 matchup against the Seahawks, Kupp will be a risky play as a WR3. — Bowen
6. Zay Flowers, WR, Baltimore Ravens
With Lamar Jackson attempting only 15 passes in a Christmas Day win over the Texans, Flowers was really quiet in this one, catching only two of five targets for 31 yards (5.1 points). That ended a four-game streak for Flowers with at least seven targets and 50 yards receiving. With the Browns defense on tap next Sunday, we can go back to the first head-to-head matchup against Cleveland in Week 8, when Flowers caught seven of 12 targets for 115 yards (18.5 points). He’ll remain a lower-tier WR2 for this game. — Bowen
Isiah Pacheco, RB, Kansas City Chiefs
What we know: In a Christmas Day game, Pacheco left because of a rib injury in the fourth quarter and did not return. Before exiting, Pacheco had only 18 yards rushing on six carries (1.8 points) against the Steelers’ defense.
What’s next: With a victory over Pittsburgh, the Chiefs locked up the No. 1 seed in the AFC, so we don’t expect Pacheco (or other key starters) to play in the Week 18 game at Denver. That will open the door for Samaje Perine, and potentially Kareem Hunt, to have an increase in usage. — Bowen
James Conner, RB, Arizona Cardinals
What we know: After entering Saturday night’s game questionable because of a knee injury, he left early in the second quarter because of an aggravation of the same ailment. Conner did not return despite desiring to do so, per ESPN’s Josh Weinfuss, finishing with six touches and 2.8 PPR fantasy points.
What’s next: Conner’s setback, coupled with the Cardinals’ Week 16 elimination from postseason contention, makes him iffy at best to appear in the season finale. Should rookie Trey Benson, who sat out Week 17 because of an ankle injury, be healed enough to play, he might take on a big workload against the San Francisco 49ers. Otherwise, expect a combination of Michael Carter, DeeJay Dallas and perhaps Tony Jones Jr. to handle the Cardinals’ rushing chores. — Cockcroft
Kendre Miller, RB, New Orleans Saints
What we know: He sustained a concussion during the second quarter of Sunday’s game and was quickly ruled out.
What’s next: Clyde Edwards-Helaire and Jamaal Williams shared the rushing chores following Miller’s absence, and seem likely to do so again in Week 18 should Miller and Alvin Kamara (groin) be unable to play. — Cockcroft
Tyjae Spears, RB, Tennessee Titans
What we know: He sustained an apparent concussion on a rushing play for a 5-yard loss during the third quarter of Sunday’s game, and was unable to return.
What’s next: Spears entered concussion protocol, and he’ll need to clear it to be able to play in Week 18. Tony Pollard (ankle, flu) sat out Sunday’s game but seems likely to be available for that game. Julius Chestnut is third on the depth chart. — Cockcroft
C.J. Gardner-Johnson, DB, Philadelphia Eagles
Gardner-Johnson delivered Sunday, scoring Philadelphia’s first points in their blowout win over the Cowboys. On the first drive of the game, Gardner-Johnson cut in front of Brandin Cooks running a slant route, picking off Cooper Rush and then running it all the way back for a touchdown. He wasn’t done: in the second quarter Rush launched a deep ball prayer again intended for Cooks, and Gardner-Johnson ran under it for the pick. In addition to the picks, Gardner-Johnson did not allow a reception as the nearest defender Sunday, per NFL Next Gen Stats.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers offensive line
Mayfield had an incredible day against the Panthers. But one reason he was able to was because of the five players in front of him. All five players across the line — tackles Tristan Wirfs and Luke Goedeke, guards Ben Bredeson and Cody Mauch and center Graham Barton — recorded a pass block win rate of 95% of or higher Sunday, and the Bucs had a team PBWR of 88%, 13th highest this season. Tampa Bay also averaged 5.1 expected rush yards per carry Sunday, per NFL Next Gen Stats — meaning blockers were in strong position at the time of handoff. Bucky Irving, Rachaad White and Sean Tucker all averaged at least 4.9 yards per carry, and Irving went for 113 yards total.
Colts D/ST
Giving up even a single touchdown to a Drew Lock-led Giants offense that had been barely functional before Sunday is a little embarrassing. Letting that unit drop 45 points on you is just brutal. Malik Nabers was dominant against Indianapolis, catching seven passes on eight targets for 171 receiving yards, including 105 yards after catch and 112 receiving yards over expectation, per NFL Next Gen Stats. Colts D/ST was a streaming option in many fantasy championships — a terrible time for negative points.
Aaron Rodgers, QB, New York Jets
A disastrous game in a disastrous season. There were almost too many bad moments to count. Two interceptions. A safety. An unsportsmanlike conduct penalty for delivering a late hit after one of his picks. Sulking after a fourth-down failure. Zero points when he left the game, and the fact that Tyrod Taylor immediately capped his first drive with a touchdown. It was all bad for Rodgers, who was credited with negative-25 expected points added by NFL Next Gen Stats — the fourth-worst total in that category this season.
On Tuesday morning (AEST) Ohio State will face Notre Dame for the college football national championship with more than 30 million people watching, and two AFL
The Super Bowl agony goes on for Lamar Jackson and the Baltimore Ravens as they are forced to stomach another tale of heartbreak t
Winners 1) Josh Allen: Whether he is voted the league's MVP or not, Allen is a singular, blunt force for the Bills. He bulled his way into the end z
The Philadelphia Eagles moved to within one game of the Super Bowl after holding on for a thrilling win in the snow against the Los Angeles Rams.The Eagles look